Ayamail vs iCloud Mail

iCloud Mail is the address many iPhone owners end up with simply because it came with the phone. On a Mac or iPad it is hard to beat. The picture changes when one child has an Android phone, a parent works on Windows and the school hands out Chromebooks, or when you would rather your email did not depend on an Apple Account. This page compares iCloud Mail and Ayamail for that kind of household: storage, UK prices, children's mail, and what each service really encrypts. Apple's facts come from Apple's support pages, read on 30 October 2026 and listed at the bottom.

Written by Ayamail editorial team · Updated 30 October 2026

Which one fits your household

If everybody at home uses an iPhone, iPad or Mac, iCloud Mail is the easy choice. It is built into Apple's apps, iCloud+ is cheap, and one subscription can be shared with up to five other family members.

If the family is mixed, Ayamail treats every device the same: webmail in any browser, and IMAP and SMTP for whichever mail app someone prefers. It also lets a parent decide who may write to a child, which iCloud Mail does not describe.

iCloud Mail and Ayamail compared

As of 30 October 2026

AyamailiCloud Mail
Free storage3 GB5 GB, shared by everything in iCloud (iCloud wins)
Smallest paid planAyamail Plus: 50 GB for £2.99 a monthiCloud+ 50 GB for £0.99 a month, 200 GB for £2.99 (iCloud wins on price per GB)
Sharing with familyAyamail Family: 6 adults and 4 child accounts share 2 TBEvery iCloud+ plan can be shared with up to five other family members
Best onAny browser, plus any IMAP app on Android, Windows, Mac, iPhone or ChromebookApple devices, where iCloud is part of the system (iCloud wins on Apple)
Other mail appsIMAP and SMTP with your normal mailbox passwordIMAP with an app-specific password; no POP
Who may write to a childApproved senders on by default; the parent can also read the child's mail, read-onlyAllowed contacts cover Phone, FaceTime, Messages and other supported apps; Apple's page does not mention Mail
Your own domainFrom Ayamail PlusWith iCloud+: up to five domains with 10 addresses each, shareable with family
Stored mailTLS in transit, kept on our servers in Germany; OpenPGP if you want itEncrypted in transit and on Apple's servers with Apple holding the keys, also with Advanced Data Protection; S/MIME optional
Company3XAYA LTD, United Kingdom (outside the EU)Apple, USA

Apple details are taken from Apple's support pages on the date shown. iCloud+ prices are UK prices and can change.

Where iCloud Mail is stronger

  • It is woven into iPhone, iPad and Mac. Nothing to install, and mail, contacts and calendar are simply there.
  • iCloud+ is inexpensive: 50 GB costs £0.99 a month and 200 GB £2.99, with 2 TB at £8.99, 6 TB at £26.99 and 12 TB at £54.99.
  • More free space: 5 GB against 3 GB on Ayamail Free, though Apple's 5 GB also holds backups and photos.
  • Custom domains with iCloud+, up to five of them, which the family can share.
  • Any iCloud+ plan can be shared with up to five other people in Family Sharing.

Where Ayamail is stronger

  • It behaves the same on Android, Windows, Chromebook and Apple devices, and your address is not tied to an Apple Account.
  • Mail apps connect over IMAP with the mailbox password. There are no app-specific passwords to generate for each device.
  • Approved senders for children, on from the first day, so unknown senders reach the parent first.
  • On Ayamail Family the parent can read a child's mailbox without changing anything in it.
  • Drive, Pass, Album and Docs are encrypted on your own device, and only you hold the key.

When not everyone has an iPhone

Apple's help page for using iCloud Mail in other apps describes IMAP with an app-specific password, and it states that POP is not supported. So on an Android phone, a Windows laptop or a school Chromebook, someone has to create a separate password at Apple for each app and type in the server settings. It works, but in a family of four with different devices that is a lot of small chores, and they come back whenever a phone is replaced.

With Ayamail, the same address opens in a browser on any computer, and any mail app that speaks IMAP signs in with the ordinary mailbox password. A teenager on Android, a grandparent on Windows and a parent on an iPhone all reach the same service the same way. Calendar and contacts open in the same browser. Ayamail does not offer CalDAV or CardDAV yet, so they do not show up in the phone's own calendar and contacts apps.

Children's mail: allowed contacts and approved senders

Apple says a child under 13, an age that varies by country, needs a parent or guardian in Family Sharing to create their Apple Account. Parents can then manage allowed contacts, and Apple lists Phone, FaceTime, Messages and other supported apps. Apple's page does not mention Mail, so there is no documented way to stop a stranger writing to a child's iCloud address.

Ayamail child accounts are for children under 15 and are created by a parent in the Family Center on Ayamail Family. Approved senders is switched on by default: mail from someone the parent has not approved is passed to the parent and does not reach the child. The family's own addresses always get through, and the child can still write to anyone. If the parent later turns approved senders off, they can choose to get a copy of mail from new senders.

On Ayamail Family the account owner can also open and read a child's mailbox. Access is read-only: the parent cannot send, cannot delete, and unread messages stay unread. Tell your child about it; it works best when nobody is surprised.

Prices in pounds

Apple's UK prices for iCloud+ are £0.99 a month for 50 GB, £2.99 for 200 GB, £8.99 for 2 TB, £26.99 for 6 TB and £54.99 for 12 TB. Per gigabyte that is cheaper than Ayamail, and we will not pretend otherwise.

Ayamail Plus is £2.99 a month for 50 GB, and Ayamail Family is £11.99 a month for 2 TB shared by 6 adults and 4 child accounts. What you pay for is a service that works the same on every device, child accounts with approved senders, and encrypted Drive, Pass, Album and Docs. The pricing page has all plans and the money-back terms.

What is encrypted, on both sides

Apple is open about this: iCloud Mail is encrypted in transit and on Apple's servers, but Apple holds the keys, and Advanced Data Protection does not change that for mail because mail has to work with the global email system. Contacts and Calendars are not covered either. Apple's own mail apps offer S/MIME if you want to protect individual messages.

Ayamail is in a similar position for mail. Connections use TLS, other servers must deliver to us encrypted, and mail is stored on our servers at Hetzner in Germany, where it is not end-to-end encrypted unless you choose OpenPGP (PGP) or send a password-protected message. Files, passwords, photos and documents in Drive, Pass, Album and Docs are different: they are encrypted on your device and only you have the key. Calendar and contacts can be encrypted. The company behind Ayamail is 3XAYA LTD, registered in the UK, which is not an EU country.

Moving from iCloud Mail to Ayamail

  1. Create your Ayamail account

    Pick Ayamail Free or a paid plan. For a family, the account owner starts Ayamail Family and adds the others in the Family Center.

  2. Make an app-specific password at Apple

    In your Apple Account settings, create an app-specific password. Ayamail's importer needs it to read your iCloud Mail over IMAP.

  3. Import your mail

    Run the import in Ayamail with your iCloud address and the app-specific password. Your iCloud mailbox stays as it is.

  4. Hand over gradually

    Keep the iCloud address for now, tell people your new one, and change the address on important accounts one by one.

All Ayamail plans in pounds

Monthly and yearly prices, plus the money-back terms.

Also weighing up Outlook.com?

The same comparison for Microsoft's free and paid mail.

Questions and answers

Can I use iCloud Mail on an Android phone?
Apple's help page describes using iCloud Mail in other apps over IMAP with an app-specific password. It works, but you set it up per app, and POP is not supported.
Can Apple read my iCloud Mail?
Apple holds the keys to iCloud Mail: Apple states that mail is not covered by Advanced Data Protection. Ayamail mail is not end-to-end encrypted either unless you use OpenPGP (PGP).
Can I stop strangers emailing my child's iCloud address?
Apple's allowed contacts cover Phone, FaceTime, Messages and other supported apps, and the page does not mention Mail. On Ayamail, child accounts under 15 only receive mail from approved senders unless the parent changes it.
Is iCloud+ cheaper than Ayamail?
Per gigabyte, yes. In the UK 200 GB costs £2.99 a month. Ayamail costs more for the space, and in return works the same on every device and includes child accounts with approved senders.
Can I bring my iCloud mail to Ayamail?
Yes. Create an app-specific password at Apple and use it in Ayamail's import. Your mail is copied over IMAP and the iCloud account is left untouched.
  • Ayamail vs Outlook.com

    Ayamail and Outlook.com compared on ads, storage, price, family sharing and child accounts. Dated and sourced, including where Outlook is stronger.

  • Ayamail vs Gmail

    Compare Ayamail and Gmail on ads, storage, price, kids' accounts and approved senders. An honest side-by-side, including where Gmail is stronger.

  • Email storage compared

    How much room Gmail, Outlook, Yahoo, iCloud, Proton, Tuta, Infomaniak, Posteo and Ayamail give, what fills a mailbox and what happens when it is full.

  • Kids' email

    Parents create an email account for children under 15 and approve who can write to them. No ads. Part of the Ayamail Family plan.