Ayamail vs Fastmail: an honest comparison

Fastmail has a loyal following among people who are happy to pay for email that is fast, ad-free and works with their own domain. If you are looking for a Fastmail alternative, it is usually for one of three reasons: you want a free plan to start with, you want one subscription that covers the whole household including the children, or you want to know exactly which country your mail lives in. This page puts the two services side by side, with every Fastmail fact taken from Fastmail's own website and help centre on the date shown.

Written by Ayamail editorial team · Updated 30 October 2026

The short answer

Fastmail is a mature, paid service with generous storage per person, Masked Email and its own apps. Ayamail has a free plan, a Family plan with child accounts where a parent approves senders, and stores mail on its own servers in Germany. Pick Fastmail for polish and storage, Ayamail for families and a free start.

Ayamail and Fastmail side by side

Fastmail prices are the US dollar amounts on Fastmail's US pricing page. Ayamail prices depend on your country and are on our pricing page.

As of 30 October 2026

AyamailFastmail
Free planYes: Free with 3 GB and one @ayamail.net addressNo. Every plan is paid, with a free trial of up to 30 days
Price for one personDepends on your country, see the pricing page$6 a month, or $5 a month when paid yearly ($60)
Storage per personFree 3 GB, Plus 50 GB, Unlimited 500 GB60 GB on Individual, Duo and Family (50 GB mail plus 10 GB files)
Plans for two or moreDuo: 1 TB shared by 2 adults. Family: 2 TB shared by up to 6 adults and 4 child accountsDuo: 2 people ($10 a month). Family: up to 6 people ($14 a month). 60 GB each
Child accounts with approved sendersYes, for children under 15 on the Family planNot described on the Fastmail pages we checked
Your own domainFrom Plus. Catch-all once your domain is verifiedIncluded on Individual, Duo and Family. Catch-all possible
Extra addresses for sign-upsAliasesMasked Email, with 1Password and Bitwarden integration
ProtocolsIMAP and SMTP (no CalDAV or CardDAV yet)JMAP, IMAP, CalDAV and CardDAV
Company3XAYA LTD, United KingdomFastmail Pty Ltd, Australia, subject to Australian law
Where mail is storedOur own servers at Hetzner in GermanyYou choose US or EU (Amsterdam). Replicas and backups are in the US
Reading mail only the recipient can openPGP or password-protected messages, built inPGP or S/MIME in third-party apps, not in Fastmail's own apps

Checked 30 October 2026. Plans and prices change; please check each provider's own pages.

Where Fastmail is better

Fastmail is a strong service, and in several areas it is ahead of us.

  • Track record: Fastmail says it has been running its service for over 20 years. Ayamail is much younger.
  • Storage for the money: every person on Individual, Duo or Family gets 60 GB. On Ayamail, the Plus plan has 50 GB.
  • Masked Email: a separate, unique address for every website, which you can switch off if it starts getting spam. It plugs into 1Password and Bitwarden, so a new address is created while you sign up.
  • Your own domain is included from Individual, the standard one-person plan, together with a catch-all that collects mail sent to any address at that domain.
  • Apps: Fastmail lists its own apps for macOS, Windows, Linux, iOS and Android, alongside the web version.
  • JMAP: Fastmail fully supports this modern standard for syncing mail, contacts and calendars. Ayamail uses IMAP and SMTP.
  • Notes and memos live in the same account, and notes sync with Apple Notes over IMAP.
  • CalDAV and CardDAV: Fastmail calendars and contacts show up in the apps built into your phone and computer. Ayamail does not offer this yet, so you use calendar and contacts in Ayamail itself.

Where Ayamail is different

  • A free plan with 3 GB, no ads and IMAP and SMTP access, so you can try it in your usual mail program without paying.
  • A Family plan built for children. A parent creates accounts for children under 15 in the Family Center. By default a child only receives mail from approved senders; mail from anyone else goes to the parent for approval. On the Family plan, the parent who manages a child account can read that child's mail. From 15, young people can have their own account.
  • More shared space for households: Duo has 1 TB for two adults, and Family has 2 TB shared by up to 6 adults and 4 children.
  • Files, photos, passwords and documents (Drive, Album, Pass and Docs) are encrypted on your own device before they are stored. Only you have the key, and we cannot read them. Calendar and contacts can be encrypted.
  • Remote images and tracking pixels are blocked by default. You can show images for a single message or for a sender you trust.

Where your mail lives: UK, EU, Australia and the US

Fastmail is an Australian company and says it acts on requests made under Australian law. Since August 2026 you can choose where the primary copy of your mailbox is kept: in the US or in Fastmail's own servers in Amsterdam. Fastmail is open about the limits. Even with the EU option, a live replica is kept in the US, and backups, logs and debugging systems are based in the US. Fastmail states that it does not offer a guarantee that data stays only in the EU. All copies are encrypted at rest.

Ayamail is run by 3XAYA LTD, a company registered in the United Kingdom, so we are not an EU company. Your mail is stored on our own servers at Hetzner in Germany. Neither choice is wrong. If it matters to you, the honest question to ask any provider is which company holds your data, under which country's law, and where every copy sits, including backups.

How your email is protected at Ayamail

Your mail is protected by an encrypted connection (TLS) to and from our servers, and we require encrypted delivery from other mail servers. Mail is stored on our own servers at Hetzner in Germany. If you want to send a message only the recipient can read, you can turn on PGP encryption or send a password-protected message.

Mail on our servers is not end-to-end encrypted unless you use PGP. Fastmail takes a similar approach: it encrypts mail at rest and supports PGP and S/MIME in other mail apps, rather than building them into its own. If keeping your inbox unreadable to the provider is your main goal, look at a service designed around that.

Moving from Fastmail to Ayamail

Your Fastmail account is not changed during the move. Messages are copied, not deleted.

  1. Create your Ayamail account

    Start on Free, or choose Plus or a larger plan if you want to bring your own domain.

  2. Import your mail over IMAP

    Ayamail's import tool connects to your Fastmail mailbox with the generic IMAP preset and copies messages and folders.

  3. Bring contacts and calendars

    Export contacts as a vCard file and calendars as ICS files from Fastmail, then import them into Ayamail.

  4. Move your domain, if you use one

    Add the domain in Ayamail, verify it and update the MX and other DNS records at your registrar. Masked Email addresses belong to Fastmail's domains, so update the logins that use them before you cancel.

Use your own domain

Bring a domain you already own from the Plus plan upwards, with aliases and a catch-all.

Switching without losing anything

Every step for moving mail, contacts and calendars from your old provider.

Compare our plans

Free, Plus, Unlimited, Duo and Family. Prices depend on your country.

Questions and answers

Is there a free alternative to Fastmail?
Fastmail has no free plan, only a trial of up to 30 days. Ayamail has a Free plan with 3 GB, one @ayamail.net address and no ads. Your own domain needs Plus or a larger plan.
Where does Fastmail store my data?
You choose the US or the EU (Amsterdam) for the primary copy. According to Fastmail's help centre, a replica is kept in the US either way, and backups and logs are in the US.
Does Fastmail support PGP?
Not in its own apps. Fastmail encrypts mail at rest and supports PGP or S/MIME in third-party mail apps. Ayamail also is not end-to-end encrypted by default, but has PGP and password-protected messages built in.
Does Ayamail have something like Masked Email?
Ayamail has aliases, and with your own verified domain you can use a catch-all. There is no password-manager integration that creates addresses automatically, as Fastmail has with 1Password and Bitwarden.
Can I give my children email with Fastmail or Ayamail?
On Ayamail's Family plan a parent creates accounts for children under 15, who by default only receive mail from approved senders. The managing parent can read the child's mail. We did not find dedicated child accounts on Fastmail's pages.

Sources

  1. Fastmail: pricing (US) (Checked 30 October 2026)
  2. Fastmail: pricing (Germany, EUR) (Checked 30 October 2026)
  3. Fastmail Help: How do I choose a subscription plan? (Checked 30 October 2026)
  4. Fastmail Help: Choosing your data residency (Checked 30 October 2026)
  5. Fastmail blog: Fastmail offers EU data region (Checked 30 October 2026)
  6. Fastmail: Fastmail vs Proton (Checked 30 October 2026)
  7. Fastmail: Masked Email (Checked 30 October 2026)
  8. Fastmail Help: Catch-all/wildcard aliases (Checked 30 October 2026)
  9. Fastmail Help: Notes (Checked 30 October 2026)
  10. Fastmail: features (Checked 30 October 2026)
  • Ayamail vs Proton Mail

    Proton encrypts stored email end to end; Ayamail does not. Ayamail adds child accounts with approved senders. Prices and features side by side.

  • Ayamail vs Gmail

    Compare Ayamail and Gmail on ads, storage, price, kids' accounts and approved senders. An honest side-by-side, including where Gmail is stronger.

  • GMX alternative

    Ayamail compared with GMX.com and GMX.co.uk: ads, free storage, IMAP, own domain and family accounts, plus how to move your mail and contacts.

  • Ad-free email providers

    Which email services show ads, which never do, and what it costs to switch them off: Outlook, Yahoo, Proton, Tuta, Infomaniak, Posteo and Ayamail.