Ayamail vs Tuta: an honest comparison

If you are weighing up Tuta and Ayamail, start with the most important difference. Tuta is the stronger choice for keeping your stored mail away from the provider's eyes, and we will not pretend otherwise. Ayamail is built for something else: working with any mail app you like, and giving a whole household, children included, one sensible place for email. This page sets out both sides, with Tuta's facts taken from Tuta's own pages.

Written by Ayamail editorial team · Updated 30 October 2026

The short version

Pick Tuta if privacy of the mail sitting on the server is your first concern. Tuta stores your whole mailbox, including subject lines, together with your address book and calendar, locked with keys that only you hold. Tuta writes that it has no access to the contents. Ayamail cannot say the same about mail.

Pick Ayamail if you want to read mail in Apple Mail, Outlook, Thunderbird or the app already on your phone, or if you need email for children with a parent in control. Tuta has no IMAP at all, and its pricing page does not describe child accounts.

Ayamail and Tuta side by side

As of 30 October 2026

AyamailTuta
Stored mailTLS in transit, stored on our servers in Germany. Not end-to-end encrypted on the server unless you use OpenPGPWhole mailbox, subject lines, contacts and calendar locked with keys only you hold; Tuta says it cannot read them
Use any mail app (IMAP and SMTP)Yes, on every plan including the free oneNo. Tuta's own apps only
Calendar and contacts syncNo CalDAV or CardDAV yet, use them in AyamailInside Tuta's apps
Own apps for phone and desktopWebmail in the browser, plus any IMAP appWeb, mobile and desktop apps, open source
Free storage3 GB1 GB
Cheapest paid planAyamail Plus, 50 GB, £2.99 a monthRevolutionary, 20 GB, €3 a month billed yearly (€3.60 monthly)
ChildrenChild accounts for under-15s on Ayamail Family, approved senders on by default, parent can read the child's mailNot described on Tuta's pricing page
Family planAyamail Family: 6 adults and 4 child accounts sharing 2 TBExtra members added through support, €3 or €8 per user a month
AdsNoneNone
Company and servers3XAYA LTD, a UK company (outside the EU); servers in GermanyGerman company in Hanover; servers in Germany

Tuta details come from Tuta's own pages, checked on the date shown. Plans and prices change, so check both sites before you choose.

Where Tuta is stronger

  • Privacy of stored mail. Your mailbox, subject lines, contacts and calendar are locked with keys only you hold, so Tuta itself cannot open them. On Ayamail, ordinary mail is readable on our servers.
  • Messages between two Tuta users are protected automatically, and you can reach outsiders with a shared password.
  • Both the company and the servers are in Germany, inside the EU. Ayamail's servers are in Germany too, but the company is British.
  • The entry paid plan costs less per month than ours, with Tuta billing in euros.
  • Tuta has its own apps for phones and computers, and their code is open source. Ayamail has webmail and works with other mail apps, but has no app of its own in the app stores.

Where Ayamail is stronger

  • IMAP and SMTP on every plan, so you can keep the mail app you already use. Tuta states plainly that it does not offer IMAP.
  • More room on the free plan: 3 GB against Tuta's 1 GB.
  • A real family plan with shared storage: 6 adults and 4 child accounts on one subscription.
  • Child accounts for children under 15, with approved senders switched on from the start.

How Ayamail protects mail, plainly put

Mail travels to and from our servers over TLS, and we insist that other mail servers deliver to us over an encrypted connection. Your mailbox lives on our own servers at Hetzner in Germany. Unlike Tuta, we hold mail on the server in a form our systems can read, so it is not end-to-end encrypted unless you add OpenPGP. When one message needs to stay between you and the recipient, switch on OpenPGP or send it as a password-protected message.

Files are different. Drive, Pass, Album and Docs are encrypted on your own device before anything is stored, and the key stays with you. Calendar and contacts can be encrypted as well. If your threat model is about the mail provider itself, Tuta is the better fit, and we would rather you knew that now.

Why IMAP matters more than it sounds

Tuta's design means mail can only be opened inside Tuta's apps. That is the price of its privacy model, and Tuta explains it openly. In daily life it means no Apple Mail, no Outlook on the work laptop, no Thunderbird with your old folders, and no backup tool that copies mail over IMAP.

With Ayamail you sign in to whichever program you like, and you can bring years of old mail with you by importing from Gmail, Yahoo, iCloud or another IMAP server. Calendar and contacts are different: they live in Ayamail itself, because we do not offer CalDAV or CardDAV yet, but you can import and export them as .ics and vCard files. If you mix devices at home and at work, that freedom is often the deciding factor.

Families and children

On Ayamail Family a parent creates a child account in the Family Center for children under 15. Approved senders is on by default: mail from someone the parent has not approved goes to the parent instead of the child, while the family's own addresses always get through. The child can still write to anyone. The account owner can also read the child's mail in a read-only view, so nothing is sent, deleted or marked as read. We say this openly because it is a real difference in privacy inside the family.

Tuta's pricing page does not describe child accounts. Families can add extra members to a Tuta plan through Tuta's support, paid per person each month, but each member is an ordinary adult account.

What it costs

Tuta's Revolutionary plan costs €3 a month when paid yearly and gives 20 GB. Legend costs €8 a month yearly for 500 GB. Ayamail Plus starts at £2.99 a month with 50 GB, and Ayamail Family is £11.99 a month for the whole household. Neither service shows ads. See our pricing page for current prices and the money-back terms.

Who should choose which

  • Journalists, activists and anyone who wants the provider unable to read stored mail: Tuta.
  • People who want the company and servers both inside the EU: Tuta.
  • Anyone who depends on Outlook, Apple Mail or Thunderbird for mail: Ayamail.
  • Parents who want a first email address for a child with a say over who can write to it: Ayamail Family.
  • If you want strong protection for single messages but also IMAP, Ayamail with OpenPGP is a middle path.

Compare Ayamail's plans

See what each plan includes, from the free plan to Ayamail Family.

Also weighing up Proton?

Proton takes a different route to private mail, with PGP at its core.

Questions and answers

Can I use Tuta with Outlook or Apple Mail?
No. Tuta says it does not support IMAP, so you need Tuta's own web, mobile or desktop apps. Ayamail supports IMAP and SMTP, so any standard mail app works.
Is Tuta more private than Ayamail?
For stored mail, yes. Tuta keeps your mailbox locked with keys only you hold. Ayamail protects mail in transit with TLS and stores it in Germany, but ordinary mail is not end-to-end encrypted unless you turn on OpenPGP.
Where is my data stored with each service?
Both store data in Germany. Tuta is a German company. Ayamail is run by 3XAYA LTD, a British company, with servers at Hetzner in Germany.
Can my child have an account?
On Ayamail Family, yes: children under 15 get a child account with approved senders, and the parent can read their mail. Tuta's pricing page does not describe child accounts.
Can I move from Tuta to Ayamail?
Because Tuta has no IMAP, our importer cannot connect to it. Look in Tuta's own help pages for the export options Tuta offers today. Whatever you can save from Tuta as files can be added to Ayamail through a desktop mail app connected over IMAP.

Sources

  1. Tuta: pricing and plans (Checked 30 October 2026)
  2. Tuta: Tuta vs StartMail (IMAP, servers) (Checked 30 October 2026)
  • Ayamail vs Proton Mail

    Proton encrypts stored email end to end; Ayamail does not. Ayamail adds child accounts with approved senders. Prices and features side by side.

  • PGP email

    What PGP does, when you need it and how to turn it on in Ayamail. Plus password-protected messages for people who do not use PGP.

  • European email providers

    Proton, Tuta, mailbox.org, Posteo, Mailo, Infomaniak and Ayamail compared: company country, server location, price and features. Honest and dated.

  • Ad-free email providers

    Which email services show ads, which never do, and what it costs to switch them off: Outlook, Yahoo, Proton, Tuta, Infomaniak, Posteo and Ayamail.