European email providers compared
Ayamail is a British company (3XAYA LTD). The UK is not in the EU. Our servers are at Hetzner in Germany. We put that first because many people looking for a European alternative to Gmail really mean a provider inside the EU, and we are not one. Below we compare seven providers based in Europe, ourselves included: where the company is registered, where the mail is kept, how stored mail is protected and what it costs. Every competitor detail comes from that provider's own pages, checked on 30 October 2026.
Written by Ayamail editorial team · Updated 30 October 2026
European is not the same as EU
Europe and the European Union are two different things, and email marketing often blurs them. Tuta, Posteo and mailbox.org are German companies and Mailo is French, so those four sit inside the EU. Proton AG and Infomaniak are Swiss, and Switzerland is not an EU member. Ayamail belongs to a company registered in England, and the UK has left the EU. Where the servers stand is a third question: a Swiss or British company can keep its servers in Germany, and Proton itself stores data in Switzerland, Germany or Norway.
Why does any of this matter? In broad terms, the GDPR covers services aimed at people in the EU wherever the company is registered. The UK has its own version, usually called the UK GDPR, and Switzerland has a separate data protection law. The company's home country decides which regulators and courts it answers to first, while the server country decides where your messages physically sit. We are not lawyers and this page is not legal advice. If a particular law matters to you, perhaps because of your work, read the provider's privacy policy and put the question to them directly.
Seven providers side by side
One row per provider. Not stated means we did not find the detail on the provider's own pages that we checked.
As of 30 October 2026
| Company country | Servers | Stored mail | Free plan | Paid from | Family / children | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Proton Mail | Switzerland (Proton AG), not in the EU | Proton-owned servers in Switzerland, Germany or Norway | Kept encrypted with your own key, PGP between Proton users | 1 GB (500 MB at first, raised by finishing a checklist) | Mail Plus $3.99 a month billed yearly (priced in USD) | Up to 6 people share up to 3 TB; child features not stated |
| Tuta | Germany (Hanover), in the EU | Germany, ISO 27001 data centres | Whole mailbox, contacts and calendar encrypted; Tuta has no access to the contents. No IMAP | 1 GB, no extra addresses, no own domain | €3 a month billed yearly (€3.60 paid monthly) | Extra members through support; the pricing page does not describe child accounts |
| mailbox.org | Germany (Berlin), in the EU | Germany | Not stated on the pages we checked | No free plan | Light: €1 a month paid annually, 2 GB of mail | Not stated |
| Posteo | Germany (Berlin), in the EU | A German data centre | Optional crypto mailbox that encrypts all stored mail | No free plan | €1 a month with 4 GB | Not stated |
| Mailo | France, in the EU | France | Not stated | 1 GB of mail with advertising banners | Premium from €1.50 a month, no ads | 5 Premium accounts for €3 a month; Mailo Junior for ages 6 to 14 with parent-approved contacts |
| Infomaniak | Switzerland, not in the EU | Switzerland only | Not stated | 20 GB of mail plus 15 GB kDrive, no ads, 100 sent messages a day, phone number needed, some countries only | Not stated | Not stated |
| Ayamail | United Kingdom (3XAYA LTD), not in the EU | Germany (Hetzner) | TLS in transit, kept on our servers. Not end-to-end encrypted unless you use PGP | 3 GB, no ads | Ayamail Plus £2.99 a month | Family: 6 adults and 4 child accounts with approved senders; the parent can read the child's mail |
Competitor details come from each provider's own pages, checked on 30 October 2026. Plans and prices change, so look again before you pay.
Where others are stronger
Several providers in the table beat us on specific rows. Here is where, plainly:
- Tuta keeps the whole mailbox, including contacts and calendar, encrypted so that Tuta itself has no access to the contents. We cannot say that about mail stored with us.
- Proton uses PGP to protect mail end-to-end between Proton users and keeps stored messages encrypted with a key that belongs to you.
- Posteo's optional crypto mailbox encrypts every stored message, and Posteo costs €1 a month, less than any Ayamail paid plan.
- Infomaniak's free address comes with 20 GB of mail and 15 GB of kDrive, a lot more than the 3 GB on our free plan.
- Tuta, Posteo, mailbox.org and Mailo are companies inside the EU. If an EU-registered company is a requirement for you, they qualify and we do not.
- Mailo Junior is free for children aged 6 to 14 and lets them exchange mail only with contacts a parent has approved. Ayamail child accounts need the paid Family plan.
- Proton's Family plan shares up to 3 TB, which is more than the 2 TB on Ayamail Family.
What Ayamail protects, and where it stops
Messages travel to and from our servers over TLS, and we insist that other mail servers use an encrypted connection when they deliver to us. Once a message arrives, it is kept on our own servers at Hetzner in Germany. Mail stored there is not end-to-end encrypted unless you use PGP, so it is not protected the way Tuta or Proton protect a stored inbox. When a message should be readable by the recipient alone, you can switch on OpenPGP or send it as a password-protected message.
Drive, Pass, Album and Docs work differently. Files, passwords, photos and documents are encrypted on your own device before they are stored, and only you have the key. Calendar and contacts can be encrypted. Mail comes with IMAP and SMTP on every plan, the free one included, so Thunderbird, Apple Mail and other mail apps work. Calendar and contacts are used in Ayamail itself, since CalDAV and CardDAV are not offered yet. There are no ads, and remote images and tracking pixels are blocked unless you choose to show them.
Children under 15 get a child account that a parent creates in the Family Center on Ayamail Family. Approved senders is switched on from the start, so mail from people the parent has not approved goes to the parent instead of the child. On Ayamail Family the account owner can also read the child's mail, read-only. We state that openly, because it matters to families with teenagers.
Questions to ask any provider
Whichever service you look at, these six questions separate marketing from facts:
- Where is the company registered? That decides which data protection law and which regulator apply first.
- In which country are the servers, and does the provider run its own hardware or rent space from a hosting company?
- Who holds the keys to stored mail: you or the provider?
- Does it offer IMAP and SMTP, so you can keep the mail app you already use? Tuta does not offer IMAP, and Proton only offers it through Proton Mail Bridge on paid plans.
- Can you export all of your mail and leave whenever you like, without asking anyone?
- What will you pay after the first year? Compare the monthly price, the yearly price and whether an introductory offer runs out.
Which one fits whom
- You want stored mail the provider cannot read and you are happy to use the provider's own apps: Tuta or Proton.
- You want a small, inexpensive mailbox from a German company and already use a desktop mail app: Posteo or mailbox.org Light.
- You want a roomy free address and a Swiss company suits you: Infomaniak, provided your country is supported and a daily sending limit is acceptable.
- You live in France or want a free address for a young child with approved contacts: Mailo and Mailo Junior.
- You want one paid plan for the whole household, with child accounts, approved senders, IMAP on every plan and servers in Germany, and a British company is fine for you: Ayamail.
Look at Ayamail's plans
Start free with 3 GB, or check what Ayamail Family costs in the UK.
Questions and answers
- Is Ayamail an EU email provider?
- No. Ayamail is run by 3XAYA LTD, a company registered in the United Kingdom, which is outside the EU. Our servers are at Hetzner in Germany, so your mailbox is stored inside the EU, but the company that runs it is not.
- Are Proton Mail and Infomaniak in the EU?
- No. Both are Swiss companies, and Switzerland is not an EU member. Proton keeps data on its own servers in Switzerland, Germany or Norway, and Infomaniak hosts its free addresses only in Switzerland.
- Which European email provider is the cheapest?
- Among the paid plans we checked, Posteo and mailbox.org Light both start at €1 a month. Posteo includes 4 GB, and mailbox.org Light gives 2 GB with annual payment. If you want to pay nothing, Proton, Tuta, Mailo, Infomaniak and Ayamail all have free plans with different limits.
- Can I keep using Outlook or Apple Mail with a European provider?
- It depends on the provider. Posteo supports IMAP, and Ayamail offers IMAP and SMTP on every plan, so ordinary mail apps work. Tuta does not support IMAP, and Proton only offers it through Proton Mail Bridge on paid plans. For the rest, check the provider's help pages before you move.
- Does server location matter if the company is outside the EU?
- Both matter, in different ways. The server location tells you where your mail is physically stored. The company's country tells you which national law and regulators it answers to. Services aimed at people in the EU have to follow the GDPR either way. If a specific legal point matters to you, ask the provider and read its privacy policy.
Sources
- Proton: Mail privacy policy (Checked 30 October 2026)
- Proton: Mail pricing (Checked 30 October 2026)
- Tuta: pricing (Checked 30 October 2026)
- Tuta: Tuta vs StartMail (Checked 30 October 2026)
- mailbox.org: plan adjustment 2026 (Checked 30 October 2026)
- mailbox.org: prices (Checked 30 October 2026)
- Posteo: features (Checked 30 October 2026)
- Mailo: home page (Checked 30 October 2026)
- Mailo FAQ: Mailo Free and Premium (Checked 30 October 2026)
- Mailo FAQ: family subscription (Checked 30 October 2026)
- Mailo Junior (Checked 30 October 2026)
- Infomaniak: free email (Checked 30 October 2026)
- Infomaniak news: free Swiss email address (Checked 30 October 2026)
Related guides
- Ayamail vs Tuta
Tuta keeps stored mail private with keys only you hold. Ayamail offers IMAP, SMTP and child accounts. An honest comparison with sources.
- Ayamail vs Proton Mail
Proton encrypts stored email end to end; Ayamail does not. Ayamail adds child accounts with approved senders. Prices and features side by side.
- Ad-free email providers
Which email services show ads, which never do, and what it costs to switch them off: Outlook, Yahoo, Proton, Tuta, Infomaniak, Posteo and Ayamail.
- Best email for kids
Gmail with Family Link, Outlook, iCloud, kids-only services and Ayamail compared on approved senders, ads, parent access and price. Dated and sourced.